The Story Behind The Worst Measles Outbreak In The European Union

Nov 24, 2018
Originally published on November 25, 2018 10:57 am

Liliana Czegledi devoted herself to keeping her daughter, Ioana, alive.

The girl had been born with a compromised immune system, a damaged heart and muscles that wouldn't work. She wasn't expected to live past her second birthday. Czegledi gave up her bartending job to care for her.

"I made sure she never caught a cold because the doctor said a cold could kill her," recalls Czegledi, 50, at her home in the village of Sînandrei in western Romania. "I only brought her into the hospital when it was absolutely necessary."

Like last spring, April 2017, just a month before Ioana was to turn 10.

Her mother had driven the girl to the pediatric hospital in the nearby city of Timisoara because she was badly dehydrated.

After Ioana came home, she broke out in spots.

"She was also throwing up her food; she was throwing up blood," Czegledi says, her voice hoarse with emotion. "I immediately called the ambulance."

Ioana had contracted measles in the hospital. She had never been vaccinated because vaccines carry bigger risks for those with compromised immune systems.

The girl was one of 59 Romanians, many of them children with compromised health, who have died since the measles epidemic began here in 2016.

Measles is a serious disease in poor countries, which account for most of the 173,000 infections recorded globally in 2017. "In Europe, we have the resources and the capacity and the vaccines to eliminate measles," says Dr. Mike Catchpole, chief scientist at the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. "So it is enormously disappointing that we are continuing to see significant outbreaks here."

The ECDC has recorded nearly 33,000 measles infections in the 28-member European Union since 2016. About half were in Romania, according to the National Institute of Public Health in Bucharest.

"The people who are susceptible to measles exist in every single country," says Dr. Dragan Jankovic, an infectious diseases specialist at the World Health Organization. "Importation of the virus is something that's not avoidable. The only way to protect a population from outbreaks and disease is to immunize your own population in the country."

It's in the air

Adriana Pistol, a medical epidemiologist, had warned in 2015 that an epidemic was coming. She directs the National Centre for Surveillance and Control of Communicable Diseases in Romania, part of the National Institute of Public Health.

Few listened. That year, only four measles cases were reported in Romania. The World Health Organization seemed confident that the disease was under control in Europe. But Pistol noticed that vaccination rates were dropping.

"Measles is [one of] the most contagious diseases in the world, so it's very, very quickly transmitted," Pistol says, speaking from her office in central Bucharest, gripping a blue mug that reads "Big Boss," a gift from her devoted staff. The virus — transmitted through coughing, sneezing or contact with infected secretions — can linger in the air.

So vaccines are an essential tool. "Vaccination coverage against measles has to be very high, at least 95 percent if you really want to not have any outbreaks," Pistol says.

Before the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine was introduced in 1963, WHO estimates that at least 2.6 million people died of the disease every year.

In Romania, health officials attribute the outbreak to various factors, including a lack of awareness of the need to vaccinate in impoverished rural communities plus an erratic supply of vaccines that sometimes didn't reach mobile populations such as the Roma.

But physicians such as Sandra Alexiu, a family doctor based in Jilava, a town outside Bucharest, suspect an anti-vaccine movement and a lack of faith in state institutions have significantly worsened the epidemic.

"I've had parents coming in who have read on social media that vaccines are made from mercury, that they're made from fetal cells, that vaccination is part of an international conspiracy to lower the population," Alexiu says, sitting in her sunny office under a clock that reads, in Romanian: Ask a Doctor, Not Doctor Google.

Alexiu has heard of people in rural areas treating measles by drinking cabbage juice or rubbing moonshine on the spots. Some even believe they can ward off the disease by wearing red scarves.

"We have to learn about the myths and how to answer every myth," she says. "We try to explain to every parent that these are wrong and you have to know what's right."

When Romania's outbreak was at its peak last year, Alexiu advised other doctors to talk to as many patients as possible about the importance of vaccination.

She reminds patients that her own son is vaccinated.

"All my patients have known him since he was a baby," she says, pointing a framed photo of a smiling little boy in a bow tie and jacket.

"That's an old photo. He's not so little anymore. He's 12 now."

Vocal anti-vaxxers

Alexiu has managed to convince many parents that vaccines are safe with this personal touch. But doctors can't reach everyone, especially those swayed by another force on social media — the anti-vaxxers.

A 2016 survey by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine showed that many of the countries with the highest skepticism of vaccines were in Europe. In France, for instance, 41 percent of those surveyed said vaccines are not safe — more than three times the global average of 12 percent.

Both Alexiu and Pistol, the chief epidemiologist, believe that parents who are against vaccination are a big reason why this outbreak grew in Romania.

"They say, 'OK, myself and my grandmother and my mother had measles, so what?' " Pistol says. "Look at us, we are smart and nice. So natural is better."

Some are followers of self-styled celebrities with an interest in health, like Olivia Steer, a former TV anchor. Steer, who promotes junk science linking vaccines to autism and cancer, has tens of thousands of followers on Facebook and has been featured on news programs.

Other anti-vaxxers are skeptical of modern medicine. Lavinia and Dan Onica, who engineer self-driving cars and live in a leafy suburb of Timisoara in western Romania, say they believe doctors are trained to treat individual ailments rather than "the whole person."

They believe that good nutrition will stave off most diseases and that vaccines do more harm that good.

"All the toxic substances that they use and the way they make your body react, that was scary for us," Lavinia says. "And we didn't want to take the chance to risk our kids' healthy life."

She says that her family has even considered leaving Romania if Parliament passes a law making vaccinations mandatory.

Patient power, pro and con

Dr. Ioana Budiu, who has a family practice in Timisoara, says many staunch anti-vaxxers just stop showing up for checkups.

"And I don't have the opportunity to talk with them and to ask about their fears," she says. "If you try to explain how many people get the disease from one person, then they start to listen and to understand a little bit. But you need a lot of time to talk with them."

Budiu has noticed that parents in her practice who are pro-vaccination are helping spread the word. Physical therapist Sebastian Miron reminds his friends that babies (who aren't eligible for measles vaccinations until they're close to a year old) are susceptible to disease from unvaccinated kids.

"I would be very stressed or mad if my child would get something from an unvaccinated kid," says Miron, stroking his son, David, as the infant gets his first round of shots in Dr. Budiu's office. David cries after the pinch of the shot, then gets distracted by a stuffed toy banana.

Across town at Timisoara's infectious diseases hospital, Dr. Virgil Musta is thrilled to hear that some Romanians are promoting vaccines to friends and neighbors. He never wants to see a repeat of what he saw last year, when part of the hospital where he works turned into a grim measles ward.

Eight children died. Musta still remembers the first one, a little boy, 8 months old, born with multiple birth defects and abandoned at another hospital.

"He was a nice boy with brown hair," Musta says. "He only weighed as much as a newborn ... He came in with sepsis."

It's the same hospital where Ioana, the 10-year-old daughter of Liliana Czegledi, died last April.

Czegledi watches the neighborhood children play outside her front yard. Her own daughter could not eat or walk on her own. She would push the girl's wheelchair around the yard.

"And I'd sing her favorite song, the one about the ducks," Czegledi says, referring to a local children's song about a duckling looking for her mother. "She'd laugh so much and smile. I wanted her to feel good."

She wipes away tears and pulls out a photograph of Ioana, a rosy-cheeked girl with feathery blond hair. In the photo, she's laughing as she sits in an oversized, custom-built stroller.

"I took her to the hospital to help her," her mother says. "And we brought her home in a coffin."

The latest data shows that measles vaccination rates in Romania for children up to 2 years of age has climbed to 90 percent because of outreach efforts by doctors and a nationwide campaign promoting vaccination.

But Adriana Pistol, Romania's chief epidemiologist, isn't celebrating. Politicians, who are afraid of the anti-vaxxer voting bloc, have shelved a bill to make vaccinations mandatory. She's predicting another outbreak.

Joanna Kakissis is a contributing international correspondent for NPR based in Athens, Greece, and covering southeastern Europe. Reach her @joannakakissis

Octavian Coman is a freelance journalist based in Bucharest, Romania.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.


Measles is one of the most contagious diseases in the world. But it's been preventable since a vaccine was introduced in 1963. So public health officials are surprised that Europe is now reporting tens of thousands of new cases in recent years. Joanna Kakissis has our story from Romania, which has the largest outbreak in the European Union.


LILIANA CZEGLEDI: Hello - Liliana.

KAKISSIS: Liliana Czegledi lives along a country road just outside the city of Timisoara in western Romania. It's here where neighborhood kids play ball in the grass that she doted on her daughter, who could not eat or walk on her own. She'd push the girl's wheelchair around the yard.

CZEGLEDI: (Through interpreter) And I'd sing her favorite song, the one about the ducks. She'd laugh so much and smile. I wanted her to feel good. (Foreign language spoken).

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Foreign language spoken).

KAKISSIS: That's when she's little? Aw. Look at her. Look at her.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Foreign language spoken).

KAKISSIS: Yeah. She has beautiful eyes.

She pulls out a photo of a girl with feathery, blonde hair and a big smile sitting in a custom-made stroller. Czegledi's eyes fill with tears.

CZEGLEDI: (Through interpreter) I miss Ioana. She was my whole universe.

KAKISSIS: Ioana had a compromised immune system, a damaged heart, muscles that did not work.

CZEGLEDI: (Through interpreter) I made sure she never caught a cold because the doctor said a cold could kill her. I only brought her into the hospital when it was absolutely necessary.

KAKISSIS: Like last year, just a month before Ioana was to turn 10, when she had to go to the hospital because she was badly dehydrated. She caught measles there. And within a week, she had died.

Dr. Virgil Musta ran the measles ward at the infectious diseases hospital where eight Romanians died that same year.

VIRGIL MUSTA: Almost all were children - unvaccinated. They couldn't be vaccinated because of their illnesses. When they get contact with the virus, they get the disease. And the final was the death.

KAKISSIS: Ioana's compromised immune system had prevented her from getting vaccinated. Another 58 Romanians, many of them children, have died since a measles epidemic broke out here in 2016. More than 15,000 have caught the virus - nearly half of the total recorded infections in the EU since 2016.

Dr. Dragan Jankovic of the World Health Organization is shocked because Europe seemed on the verge of eradicating measles.

DRAGAN JANKOVIC: We have high-quality vaccines since '60s, '70s, which are routinely used in all countries in the region. And we would expect to see that the population in the region is protected.

KAKISSIS: And to be protected, 95 percent of the population must be vaccinated. Immunization rates had dropped to 80 percent in Romania in the years before the outbreak. Public health officials suspect a big reason is a loss of faith in vaccines.

SANDRA ALEXIU: There's lots of fake doctors and fake news on vaccination or on any other medical subject.

KAKISSIS: That's family doctor Sandra Alexiu. And she's heard examples of that fake news in her practice outside Bucharest, that the measles vaccine is made of mercury or fetal cells or that there is an international conspiracy to lower the population.

ALEXIU: And we try to explain to every parents that these are wrong. You have to know what's right.

KAKISSIS: And this is a big part of what Romania is doing to control the current outbreak, talking to as many parents as possible. Dr. Alexiu tells them her own son is vaccinated. His photo is in her exam room.

He's that little boy there in the bow tie and the jacket.

ALEXIU: Yes. Yes. He's not so little anymore.

KAKISSIS: But doctors cannot convince everyone, including engineers Lavinia and Dan Onica. They say they just don't believe vaccines are safe for kids.

LAVINIA ONICA: All the toxic substances that they use and the way they make your body react, that was scary for us. And yeah. We didn't want to take the chance to risk our kid's healthy life.

KAKISSIS: Outreach efforts and a national awareness campaign have pushed measles coverage here to about 90 percent. But health officials say that's still not high enough to prevent another outbreak. For NPR News, I'm Joanna Kakissis in Timisoara, Romania. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.